I bought this in bulk awhile back here on Woot and was very disappointed in the odor. I say odor not smell for a reason. It smells like moldy dog food. I can’t say how well it works. I didn’t do a germ test on my hands. I hear their Gel product is better. It has a lavender scent. Really wish I had gone that route. I cannot and do not recommend the “unscented” liquid/spray.