I’ll add my .02,
I to ordered an 8gb G1 a few weeks back from Woot! and am thoroughly enjoying the unit. The music selection/depth of music is terrific, as is the ability to create and share custom stations. A lot of folks are migrating over from satellite radio, and it’s easy to see why. The music, programming and ability to create and tweak custom stations is worth every penny.
With that said, it is not without it’s problems and this is not a product you can simply expect to work, straight out of the box, as advertised. They have released 2 firmware updates in the past couple months. The first update caused significant problems for folks, which seem to be fixed with the update that came out a week or so ago.
The G1 is also a very finicky device. Just look at it the wrong way, and it won’t refresh your stations, or can’t connect to your network, or can’t connect to Slacker. But, massage it a little, say nice things, and be patient. The next thing you know, it’s connecting just fine. Sometimes, the problems it has are just inexplicable, random and go away as fast as they came.
Also understand that the 8gb is divided into 2 partitions, about 4 gbs for the “radio” part, and about 4 gbs for MP3’s. The partitions are fixed and locked. You cannot put 8gbs worth of MP3’s on the device, nor can you load up the device with 8 gbs of “radio” content. If you don’t load up mp3’s, 4 gbs is essentially wasted or unused. There is no plan from Slacker on changing this.
Finally, connecting and refreshing can really only be done via wireless, or a USB connection to a p.c. running WinXP (a Vista fix is in the works). Wireless is clearly the way to go, but some folks have reported difficulties getting through their router’s encryption/security. I just turned my security off cause it’s in the basement of my house. Going through the USB is a whole 'nother issue altogether. The USB refresh uses Windows built-in Internet Connection Sharing. This can create IP address conflicts with other network addresses in the house. If you don’t know what I’m talking about, this device is not for you as it requires you to resolve this conflict on your own. All station creation/updates is also done through a web interface through the Slacker site. They have dropped support for a standalone software player. If you’re not using the most recent version of IE, you might experience some difficulties (e.g. some people keep finding bugs when using FireFox).
The support from Slacker is very good, albeit limited to Forums, email and online chat during West Coast business hours. There have been enough problems, and enough folks resolving them, that it’s a good bet if you have an issue someone else has already been there and there is some solution. Worst case, you send it in to Slacker for warranty support (at your expense) or back to Woot! for a refund.
Just to be clear, if you’re patient, don’t panic when something goes wrong, are remotely technically sophisticated, and understand how to use support forums this is worth every bit of $70.00. I’m tempted to grab another as a gift for my wife. We were listening the other day at dinner, and she commented on how much better the music is as compared to Sirius/XM (we have 2 satrads, one in each car) because the variety and depth is truly that much better than what we’re getting from Sirius.
hth,
jeff