The Debunker: Can Mormons Drink Coke?

THE DEBUNKER On May 8, 1886 in Atlanta, Georgia, two men tried to mix up a batch of a new pain reliever for their pharmacy. The result was so delicious they marketed it as a soft drink instead, and Coca-Cola was born. Coke turned 133 years old this month, but any brand that's been so beloved for so long is liable to accumulate its share of folklore. Take a brief, refreshing pause to correct your carbonated conjectures about Coke with Jeopardy!'s Ken Jennings.

The Debunker: Can Mormons Drink Coke?

Granted, this is a myth that comes up more often for me than it does for 99.9% of you, since I am (a) Mormon and (b) a big Coke drinker. But it seems pretty persistent:

In a way, I’m flattered and impressed when my soda choice is questioned, because at least it means the other person is aware that members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (“the Mormons!”) don’t drink caffeinated beverages like coffee or tea. This is a plot point in the “Spooky Mormon Hell Drink” number of Broadway’s The Book of Mormon, which has helped educate America on this point. In that musical’s vision of Mormon hell, giant forbidden Starbucks cups gyrate in the underworld alongside Hitler, Jeffrey Dahmer, and Johnnie Cochrane.

The Debunker

But, confusingly, the Mormon prohibition on coffee and tea is not a prohibition on caffeine. The canonized Mormon health code is called the "Word of Wisdom," and was given to the religious movement in 1833 by its founder, Joseph Smith. It prohibits "wine or strong drink" and "tobacco," which explains why your Mormon acquaintances are non-smoking teetotalers. But it also mentions "hot drinks," which is where the confusion begins. In the 1920s, the health tips in the Word of Wisdom became mandatory for temple-attending Latter-day Saints, and at the point the interpretation of "hot drinks" was standardized as "tea and coffee." Cocoa and herbal tea are hot, but fine. Iced tea and iced coffee are cold, but not fine. Given those guidelines, it's easy to assume that caffeine, the actual psychoactive drug, is the forbidden fruit here, and that Coke would therefore be soda non grata, but that's never made theologically official. The church stayed out of the cola wars, repeating that "habit-forming drugs" were of course bad news, but the doctrinal prohibition was only on coffee and tea.

Culturally, many Mormons have avoided caffeinated soda just to be on the safe side of God's wrath. But that practice appears to be waning. In 2017, for the first time, caffeinated Coke appeared in vending machines on the campus of Brigham Young University and church offices in Salt Lake City. Apparently, my cola habit wasn't apostate; it was just slightly ahead of the curve.

Quick Quiz:Donny and Marie Osmond never did ads for caffeinated sodas, but in the 1970s and 1980s they were the TV pitch-Mormons for what sugary non-caffeinated drink?

Ken Jennings is the author of twelve books, most recently Planet Funny and co-hosts the most important podcast in human history, Omnibus. He's also the proud owner of an underwhelming Bag o' Crap. Follow him at ken-jennings.com or on Twitter as @KenJennings.

1 Like

Hawaiian Punch

I’m glad you got him for these. They always seem kind of innocuous and boring from the headline but there’s always soemthing about the way he frames the answer that kind of keeps you going along and say: “Hunh.”

I was always lead to believe that Caffeine free versions of soda were plentiful in Utah for this very reason. Even CF versions of soda that i didnt know existed. So the cola companies know that theres still a market to be had for this option in Utah and the rest of Deseret.

That is true. I have had many friends wager with me that there is a caffeine free Mt Dew. They were positive no such thing existed but in Utah (and other states), there sure is.

There is caffeine free Mountain Dew, which strikes me as an abomination. In Canada there is some law about added caffeine (which I am too lazy to look up) and my Canadian friend brought me back a caffeine free Mt. Dew can as proof. Who knew that all Canadians are Mormon!